What does it mean to say God shall destroy?

In 1 Corinthians 3:17 it speaks of God destroying a man for defiling the temple.


Now the question to be considered is whether this destruction is eternal or what not? We often read such verses as such, and not to say that there are no verses that mean eternal destruction, but context should be considered.

The Pagan is in Danger of Hell Fire, the Carnal Christian is not

In response to Thomas Manton who said this, quoted in Gordon H. Clarks - What is Saving Faith, "'A man may be right in opinion and judgment, but of vile affections; and a carnal Christian is in as great danger as a pagan, or idolater, or heretic. . . .'"

Clark responds, "That a carnal Christian is in as great danger as a pagan is unscriptural. No one is to be commended for his carnality. Paul berated the carnal Christians in Corinth. But though their works shall be burned up, yet they themselves shall be saved. The carnal Christian is even somewhat better off than this. Since justification inevitably process sanctification,  the most depraved sinner who is born again must improve, perhaps slowly and with much difficulty, or sometimes with the success of John Newton. The pagan is in danger of Hell fire; the carnal Christian is not. To the extent that Manton depends on this false premise, to that extent his argument is vitiated." - What is Saving Faith

Needless to say we must understand the point of 1 Corinthians 3. Joseph Hussey strikes at the point of the passage in his work against Offerings.

Joseph Hussey says, "We must preach Effectual Grace, it being most suited to further God's building. So the words are in 1 Cor. 3:9, 'ye are God's building.' To this purpose, the Holy Ghost delights much to use the word instruction, which signifies a building upon. 'Tis instructing sinners, building up their principles, as grace, life and power upon Christ, which the Holy Ghost hath first laid into their hearts by the preaching of the Gospel. An Operation of the Spirit carries on God's building; but offers of Grace, proposals, or tenders of Salvation, neither instruct nor build up God's elect in the true mysteries of Grace and Salvation. Right preaching is a building of the new-born soul upon God's foundation, Christ. For why do I preach Grace, if God does not work by Grace? Better put on sackcloth and lie in the dust, and cry, Lord, show me thy truth, and let me not go on my own errand." - God's Operation of Grace, Pg. 189

1 Corinthians 8:11

"A much better attempt is to examine the verb apollumi and determine whether in every case it means destruction in hell. We have seen that it often does, but let us look at some of the other ninety-two instances. In Matthew 10:42 and Luke 15:4, 8, 9, 24, 32 and 33, it means 'lose': to lose a coin, to lose a son. Luke 15:17 refers to perishing of hunger. Compare Matthew 5:29, 30; 9:17; John 6:12; 2 John 8; and others.
The conclusion is that since the lost coin was later found, there is no linguistic reason to suppose that apollumi has to mean final, irretrievable destruction in hell. Therefore, only those who want to invent a contradiction in the Bible will so understand it." - Gordon H. Clark, 1 Corinthians