I am reading St. Augustine On the Holy Trinity. Augustine does not define his terms. But I do like what he says here:
"The Son of God is both understood to be equal to the Father according to the form of God in which He is, and less than the Father according to the form of a servant which He took; in which form He was found to be not only less than the Father, but also less than the Holy Spirit; and not only so, but less even than Himself...." - St. Augustine, 2.1.2
Showing posts with label Incarnation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Incarnation. Show all posts
Tuesday, December 17, 2019
Thursday, January 14, 2016
Shedd's view presents changes in the Trinity?
"Shedd's material begins on page 278 of volume two. There he says, 'The God-man was a new person.' since Shedd will deny that the man Jesus was a person, this assertion implies certain changes and alterations in the Second Person of the Trinity. Indeed he is a very specific, for on page 281 he adds, 'The Trinity itself is not altered or modified by the Incarnation. Only the Second Person is modified.' Coming from an intelligent and well-educated Christian, this is amazing. The Second Person of the Trinity is as immutable as the other two. Furthermore, if the Second Person suffered alteration, it would modify the Trinity as whole. The Trinity, if I may use the language, is a complex of three Persons. Clearly if one changes, the complex changes. It will have different constituents. Certainly this violates the basic Christian doctrine and destroys all confidence in what may be said of the Incarnation." - Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 47
John Gill kind of reiterates this fact of the incarnation:
"Nor is the unchangeableness of the divine nature to be disproved by the incarnation of Christ; for though he, a divine Person, possessed of the divine nature, was made flesh, or became man; the divine nature in him was not changed into the human nature, nor the human nature into the divine, nor a third nature made out of them both; was this the case, the divine nature would have been changeable; but so it was not; for as it has been commonly said, 'Christ remained what he was, and assumed what he was not;' and what he assumed added nothing to his divine person; he was only manifested in the flesh; he neither received any perfection, nor imperfection, from the human nature; though that received dignity and honour by its union to him, and was adorned with the gifts and graces of the Spirit without measure, and is now advanced at the right hand of God." - John Gill, The Body of Divinity, Pg. 37
The incarnation did not change the Son of God. Nothing was added to Him when he assumed the nature of man.
John Gill kind of reiterates this fact of the incarnation:
"Nor is the unchangeableness of the divine nature to be disproved by the incarnation of Christ; for though he, a divine Person, possessed of the divine nature, was made flesh, or became man; the divine nature in him was not changed into the human nature, nor the human nature into the divine, nor a third nature made out of them both; was this the case, the divine nature would have been changeable; but so it was not; for as it has been commonly said, 'Christ remained what he was, and assumed what he was not;' and what he assumed added nothing to his divine person; he was only manifested in the flesh; he neither received any perfection, nor imperfection, from the human nature; though that received dignity and honour by its union to him, and was adorned with the gifts and graces of the Spirit without measure, and is now advanced at the right hand of God." - John Gill, The Body of Divinity, Pg. 37
The incarnation did not change the Son of God. Nothing was added to Him when he assumed the nature of man.
Heretical views on the Incarnation
Nestorianism - 5th Century
This heresy taught that Mary only gave birth to Jesus’ human nature. The founder of the heresy, Nestorius, believed Jesus was really two separate persons, and only the human Jesus was in Mary’s womb. If that was true, then Jesus was not God incarnate while in the womb.
Monophysitism - 5th Century
This heresy taught that Jesus’ humanity was absorbed by His divinity. The heresy is Monophysite in nature, derived from the Greek words “mono” (one) and “physis” (nature). In essence, the heresy claimed Jesus had only one nature (something new and different than the Divine or human nature that God and humans have, respectively). Instead, this heresy taught a third unique nature was possessed by Jesus; a blend or mixture of the human and the Divine.
Apollinarianism - 4th Century
This heresy denied the true and complete humanity of Jesus. Led by Appollinaris the Younger, bishop of Laodicea in Syria, this heresy Jesus did not have a human mind, but instead had a mind that was completely Divine. The heresy lessened the human nature of Jesus in order to reconcile the manner in which Jesus could be both God and man at the same time.
Docetism - 2nd Century
This heresy was coined from the Greek word, “dokesis” meaning “to seem”. It taught that Jesus only appeared to have a body and was not truly incarnate. Docetists viewed matter as inherently evil, and therefore rejected the idea that God could actually have a body. By denying Jesus truly had a body, they also denied He suffered on the cross and rose from the dead.
Of course with all of these heretical views I must say Nestorianism is used a lot against those who do have the correct viewpoint of the Incarnation. The problem is not with 'Nestorian' itself but rather the problem is that this heresy has not been clearly defined. The terms used here are unclear.
This heresy taught that Mary only gave birth to Jesus’ human nature. The founder of the heresy, Nestorius, believed Jesus was really two separate persons, and only the human Jesus was in Mary’s womb. If that was true, then Jesus was not God incarnate while in the womb.
Monophysitism - 5th Century
This heresy taught that Jesus’ humanity was absorbed by His divinity. The heresy is Monophysite in nature, derived from the Greek words “mono” (one) and “physis” (nature). In essence, the heresy claimed Jesus had only one nature (something new and different than the Divine or human nature that God and humans have, respectively). Instead, this heresy taught a third unique nature was possessed by Jesus; a blend or mixture of the human and the Divine.
Apollinarianism - 4th Century
This heresy denied the true and complete humanity of Jesus. Led by Appollinaris the Younger, bishop of Laodicea in Syria, this heresy Jesus did not have a human mind, but instead had a mind that was completely Divine. The heresy lessened the human nature of Jesus in order to reconcile the manner in which Jesus could be both God and man at the same time.
Docetism - 2nd Century
This heresy was coined from the Greek word, “dokesis” meaning “to seem”. It taught that Jesus only appeared to have a body and was not truly incarnate. Docetists viewed matter as inherently evil, and therefore rejected the idea that God could actually have a body. By denying Jesus truly had a body, they also denied He suffered on the cross and rose from the dead.
Of course with all of these heretical views I must say Nestorianism is used a lot against those who do have the correct viewpoint of the Incarnation. The problem is not with 'Nestorian' itself but rather the problem is that this heresy has not been clearly defined. The terms used here are unclear.
Wednesday, January 13, 2016
The divine second person of the Holy Trinity and the incarnation
"Nor is the unchangeableness of the divine nature to be disproved by the incarnation of Christ; for though he, a divine Person, possessed of the divine nature, was made flesh, or became man; the divine nature in him was not changed into the human nature, nor the human nature into the divine, nor a third nature made out of them both; was this the case, the divine nature would have been changeable; but so it was not; for as it has been commonly said, 'Christ remained what he was, and assumed what he was not;' and what he assumed added nothing to his divine person; he was only manifested in the flesh; he neither received any perfection, nor imperfection, from the human nature; though that received dignity and honour by its union to him, and was adorned with the gifts and graces of the Spirit without measure, and is now advanced at the right hand of God." - John Gill, The Body of Divinity, Pg. 37
The incarnation did not change the Son of God. Nothing was added to Him when he assumed the nature of man.
The incarnation did not change the Son of God. Nothing was added to Him when he assumed the nature of man.
Wednesday, September 16, 2015
Christ is both God and Man
"The relationship that obtains between the Logos, the Second Person of the Trinity, and Jesus is unique, unlike that between the Logos and every other man who comes into the world (see John 1:9). The Logos did not merely light the mind of Christ; the Logos Himself is fully in Christ. Christ could therefore say, 'I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life.' No mere prophet could make such an astounding claim. Prophets, inspired by God, possess some of the divine propositions, Christ, however, possesses them all, as the author of Hebrews argues in his first chapter. All the treasures of wisdom and knowledge are in Christ, for in Him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead bodily.
If, as seems to be the case, we now have a solution to the puzzles of the Incarnation, a solution that avoids the contradictions and meaningless words of the traditional formulations, a solution that is supported by Scripture itself, we are obliged to accept it. Jesus Christ was and is both God and man, a divine person and a human person. To deny either is to fall into error. Once the key terms are defined and clearly understood, the Incarnation is an even more stupendous and awe-inspiring miracle than the Church has hitherto surmised." - J.W.R., Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 77-78
If, as seems to be the case, we now have a solution to the puzzles of the Incarnation, a solution that avoids the contradictions and meaningless words of the traditional formulations, a solution that is supported by Scripture itself, we are obliged to accept it. Jesus Christ was and is both God and man, a divine person and a human person. To deny either is to fall into error. Once the key terms are defined and clearly understood, the Incarnation is an even more stupendous and awe-inspiring miracle than the Church has hitherto surmised." - J.W.R., Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 77-78
What suffered on the cross? Nature or Person?
"The creeds and the volumes on theology, mindful of the heresies prior to A.D. 451, deny that Christ was a human person. They use the phrase 'two distinct natures and one Person forever.' With great uniformity they refuse to define nature. Now this leads to extreme difficulties.
If Jesus was not a human person, who or what suffered on the cross? The Second Person could not have suffered, for Deity is impassible. One of the heresies of the early ages, as mentioned before, was Patripassianism. Substituting a modal trinity for the three distinct Persons, the theory requires the Father to have been crucified. But to require the Second Person, as such, to suffer is equally impossible. The Westminster Confession describes him as 'a most pure Spirit, invisible, without body, parts, or passions' (II, 1). If then the Second Person could not suffer, could a 'nature' suffer? Perhaps some few readers have heard of Isaac Watts' not so popular hymn with its inference concerning children.
Dogs delight to bark and bite
For 'tis their nature to.
If, then, theologically undefined nature is certain qualities or characteristics, such as susceptibility to fatigue, aptitude for learning, joy, sorrow, or, to extend the list beyond the life of Christ, jealousy, irascibility, sullenness - if nature is such qualities can any one of them suffer pain? Can even a human, physical body suffer? If that were the case a corpse could suffer. On the contrary, only a spirit, a soul (including the souls of animals), or a person can suffer. Apparently demons can suffer (Luke 8:31; Matthew 8:29, in which one should note the word torment), yet they have no bodies." - Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 67-68
If Jesus was not a human person, who or what suffered on the cross? The Second Person could not have suffered, for Deity is impassible. One of the heresies of the early ages, as mentioned before, was Patripassianism. Substituting a modal trinity for the three distinct Persons, the theory requires the Father to have been crucified. But to require the Second Person, as such, to suffer is equally impossible. The Westminster Confession describes him as 'a most pure Spirit, invisible, without body, parts, or passions' (II, 1). If then the Second Person could not suffer, could a 'nature' suffer? Perhaps some few readers have heard of Isaac Watts' not so popular hymn with its inference concerning children.
Dogs delight to bark and bite
For 'tis their nature to.
If, then, theologically undefined nature is certain qualities or characteristics, such as susceptibility to fatigue, aptitude for learning, joy, sorrow, or, to extend the list beyond the life of Christ, jealousy, irascibility, sullenness - if nature is such qualities can any one of them suffer pain? Can even a human, physical body suffer? If that were the case a corpse could suffer. On the contrary, only a spirit, a soul (including the souls of animals), or a person can suffer. Apparently demons can suffer (Luke 8:31; Matthew 8:29, in which one should note the word torment), yet they have no bodies." - Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 67-68
A person is what he thinks
"Aside from whatever objections will be immediately raised against this uncommon conclusions, theologians will complain that this reduces the Trinity to one Person because, being omniscient, they all have, or are, the same complex. This objection is based on a blindness toward certain definite Scriptural information. I am not at the moment referring only to the eternal generation of the Son and the eternal procession of the Spirit. I am referring to the complex of truths that form the Three Persons. Though they are equally omniscient, they do not all know the same truths. Neither the complex of truths we call the Father nor those we call the Spirit has the proposition, 'I was incarnated.' This proposition occurs only in the Son's complex. Other examples are implied. The Father cannot say, 'I walked from Jerusalem to Jericho.' Nor can the Spirit say, 'I begot the Son.' Hence the Godhead consists of three Persons, each omniscient without having precisely the same content. If this be so, no difficulty can arise as to the distinctiveness of human persons. Each one is an individual complex. Each one is his mind or soul. Whether the propositions be true or false, a person is the propositions he thinks. I hope that some think substance to be a subterfuge." -Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 54-55
Labels:
Definitions,
Incarnation,
Knowledge,
Persons,
Thinking,
Trinity
H.C. Powell's argument makes humanity divinity
"The pervasive and most annoying difficulty that plagues this whole subject is the deficiency in definition. The crucial nouns (not concepts) are ambiguous, or actually meaningless. On page 149 Powell declares, 'The chief point which was established in regard to both the Holy Trinity and to the . . . Incarnation, was that a real difference was to be recognized between essence, or nature, and personality. If there was no such real difference, then the Sabellian conception of God must be true.' The reader should recall that Sabellianism is the theory of a Unitarian modal trinity. Now, if essence means definition, which is its only suitable meaning, and if personality is a part of that definition, it is hard to see how defining the Father to include personality prevents one from including personality in the somewhat different definition of the Son. Powell's argument implies that all human individuals are one individual because every one of them is a person.
Powell goes even further. Continuing on page 149 he argues, or rather, asserts, 'if there was no distinction between person and nature [nature, he had previously identified with essence], it would seem to follow that there could be no separation in our Incarnate Lord between his Divinity and his humanity, in which case he could not have been really man, as we are.'
In the first place, however, according to the orthodox doctrine, Christ was not really man as we are, for we are persons and Christ was only a 'nature.' In the second place, Powell wants to define person in one way and nature in another way, even though he had earlier identified nature with essence, or definition. The nature is the definition of the person. How this prevents us from separating divinity from humanity, as he says it does, is not at all clear. Condense his argument: Unless person and nature are distinct, the definition of divinity is precisely the definition of humanity." - Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 30-31
Powell goes even further. Continuing on page 149 he argues, or rather, asserts, 'if there was no distinction between person and nature [nature, he had previously identified with essence], it would seem to follow that there could be no separation in our Incarnate Lord between his Divinity and his humanity, in which case he could not have been really man, as we are.'
In the first place, however, according to the orthodox doctrine, Christ was not really man as we are, for we are persons and Christ was only a 'nature.' In the second place, Powell wants to define person in one way and nature in another way, even though he had earlier identified nature with essence, or definition. The nature is the definition of the person. How this prevents us from separating divinity from humanity, as he says it does, is not at all clear. Condense his argument: Unless person and nature are distinct, the definition of divinity is precisely the definition of humanity." - Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 30-31
What is the definition of a person?
"It is now time to identify the fatal flaw in the Chalcedonian Symbol, or, more broadly, to face the very real difficulties in formulating a theory of the Incarnation that is both Biblical and intelligible. The great defect in the Creed is the absence of definitions. Its bishop-authors did not explain, and probably did not themselves know the meanings of 'rational soul,' 'consubstantial,' 'nature,' 'subsistence,' and above all 'person.' This was said a few pages ago, but it needs constant emphasis.
. . .
Now, the trouble with the Creed is not that it contains an ambiguous word. The trouble is that there are so many of them. If psuches logikes causes minimum difficulty, how shall we translate omoousion, phuseon, the Latin theatrical mask persona, and especially prosopon? Nor is translation the main difficulty. If upostasis or persona means person, we still must form a definition of person. Can one person have two wills and two intellects? Christ is commonly said to have had two wills, though his human will does not make him a person. What in addition to will and intellect is necessary to make a human body a human person? The human 'nature' of Christ is supposed to have lacked an essential characteristic of a person. What was it that he did not have? How can he be true man without being a human person? Merriam Webster defines person as a character in a stage play, a specific kind of individual character, a being characterized by rational apprehension, rationality, and a moral sense, an individual human being. Was Jesus any of these, or none? Is it not plausible that the Church Fathers did not understand what they were saying? Is it not desirable therefore to give some serious attention to the Incarnation? And while not all persons are men, all men are persons." - Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 15-17
. . .
Now, the trouble with the Creed is not that it contains an ambiguous word. The trouble is that there are so many of them. If psuches logikes causes minimum difficulty, how shall we translate omoousion, phuseon, the Latin theatrical mask persona, and especially prosopon? Nor is translation the main difficulty. If upostasis or persona means person, we still must form a definition of person. Can one person have two wills and two intellects? Christ is commonly said to have had two wills, though his human will does not make him a person. What in addition to will and intellect is necessary to make a human body a human person? The human 'nature' of Christ is supposed to have lacked an essential characteristic of a person. What was it that he did not have? How can he be true man without being a human person? Merriam Webster defines person as a character in a stage play, a specific kind of individual character, a being characterized by rational apprehension, rationality, and a moral sense, an individual human being. Was Jesus any of these, or none? Is it not plausible that the Church Fathers did not understand what they were saying? Is it not desirable therefore to give some serious attention to the Incarnation? And while not all persons are men, all men are persons." - Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 15-17
The Second person of the Trinity was not formed in Mary; but Christ was born of a woman
"The next heresy was that of Nestorius, who died sometime after A.D. 440. Even if the reports apply more to his disciples than to him, we know more about him than about other heretics because Cassian (360-432?) wrote sixty-nine pages of double columns (in the Post-Nicene Fathers) under the title The Seven Books of John Cassian on the Incarnation of the Lord, Against Nestorius. But though thus indebted to him, we cannot fully trust him, for, like the other Fathers, he uses too much invective. At the beginning of his treatise he describes Nestorius as a hydra, who hisses against us with deadly tongues. Book VI, Chapter vi starts with 'O you heretic . . . you wretched madman' and continues in VI, ix with 'What are you vomiting forth?' To which add, 'you wretched, insane, obstinate creature' (VI, xviii).
There is another and less dishonorable reason for reading Cassian and the other Fathers, with some suspicion. Unfortunately it applies to all authors. Even when modern scholars document their studies, it is always possible that they misunderstand some of their quotations. But this danger is greater when the subject matter is new, unfamiliar, and chaotic. The present writer will now select what he thinks are the most important of Cassian's references to Nestorius' theology. But the going is not smooth: Irrelevancies and fallacies beset us.
Nestorius, then, taught that Christ was born as a mere man (I, iii). A footnote at II, vi (p. 561, Nicene Fathers) reads, Nestorius maintained that 'that which was formed in the womb of Mary was not God himself.'' But this is no heresy. The Second Person of the Trinity was not formed in Mary. The Logos was never formed at all. He is eternal. Hence the argument against Nestorius, at this point, is a failure. Even the phrase from I,iii is unobjectionable, though perhaps too easily misunderstood. Christ was indeed born as mere men are, if this means from a woman's womb. But his conception was not that of an ordinary human baby. The trouble is that the language is loose, and Cassian too easily settles upon one interpretation. one should not be too surprised at this. When a group of men begin to discuss an utterly new subject, the terminology is bound to be imperfect." - Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 10-11
There is another and less dishonorable reason for reading Cassian and the other Fathers, with some suspicion. Unfortunately it applies to all authors. Even when modern scholars document their studies, it is always possible that they misunderstand some of their quotations. But this danger is greater when the subject matter is new, unfamiliar, and chaotic. The present writer will now select what he thinks are the most important of Cassian's references to Nestorius' theology. But the going is not smooth: Irrelevancies and fallacies beset us.
Nestorius, then, taught that Christ was born as a mere man (I, iii). A footnote at II, vi (p. 561, Nicene Fathers) reads, Nestorius maintained that 'that which was formed in the womb of Mary was not God himself.'' But this is no heresy. The Second Person of the Trinity was not formed in Mary. The Logos was never formed at all. He is eternal. Hence the argument against Nestorius, at this point, is a failure. Even the phrase from I,iii is unobjectionable, though perhaps too easily misunderstood. Christ was indeed born as mere men are, if this means from a woman's womb. But his conception was not that of an ordinary human baby. The trouble is that the language is loose, and Cassian too easily settles upon one interpretation. one should not be too surprised at this. When a group of men begin to discuss an utterly new subject, the terminology is bound to be imperfect." - Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 10-11
Thursday, February 26, 2015
What is the Essence of a thing?
"We, then, following the holy Fathers, all with one consent, teach men to confess one and the same Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, the same perfect in Godhead and also perfect in manhood, truly God and truly man, of a reasonable [rational: psuches logikes] soul and body; consubstantial with the Father according to the Godhead, and consubstantial with us according to the Manhood; in all things like unto us, without sin; begotten before all ages of the Father according to the Godhead, and in these latter days, for us and for our salvation, born of the Virgin Mary, the Mother of God, according to the Manhood; one and the same Christ, Son, Lord, Only-begotten, to be acknowledged in two natures, inconfusedly, unchangeably, indivisibly, inseparably; the distinction of natures being by no means taken away by the union, but rather the property of each nature being preserved, and concurring in one Person and one Subsistence [en prosopon kai mian upostasin] not parted or divided into two persons, but one and the same Son, and only-begotten, God the Word, the Lord Jesus Christ, as the prophets from the beginning [have declared] concerning him, and the Lord Jesus Christ himself has taught us, and the Creed of the holy Fathers has handed down to us." - The Creed of Chalcedon
"In order to understand the creedal statement, one must begin somewhere. There must be a pou sto, a point d'appui, a basic agreement on a fundamental term. Otherwise we shall drown in an ocean of ambiguity. No choice is better than the Nicene term hypostasis. This earliest of all creeds affirms that the Godhead is mia ousia and tres upostaseis. The term ousia is a participial noun from the verb to be; the translation commonly is being. A dog is a being, a rock is a being; but if ousia is simply a form of the verb am, are, is, be, then since there are dreams, dreams are: They are beings. Sometiems the term reality is used. But dreams, especially bad dreams, are real: They are real bad dreams. Plato claimed that his Ideas were realities: The Idea of Justice, the Idea of Man, the Idea of Horse, and the Idea of Number are realities. Therefore the term ousia is not a so good a basic term as hypostasis.
Another form of the verb 'to be' is esse or essence. The term can be useful, if defined. To illustrate: Someone sees a new gadget, or an animal he has never seen before. He asks, 'What is it?' His friend replies, 'It is this sort of gadget or this sort of animal.' In ordinary conversations the answer is usually incomplete, but if the friend is at all knowledgeable he gives a part of the definition. The full answer to the question 'What is it?' is the definition. Now, if the theologians had been content, or able to use the term unambiguously, a great deal of confusion would have been avoided. The essence is the definition. The essence of a plane triangle is an area bounded by three straight lines. The phrase 'it is of the essence. . .' means it is a part of the definition. Unfortunately many theologians do not explicitly say this, but often by usage deny it. In an historical survey, however, the author must reproduce the blunders of those whom he quotes."
Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 5-6
"In order to understand the creedal statement, one must begin somewhere. There must be a pou sto, a point d'appui, a basic agreement on a fundamental term. Otherwise we shall drown in an ocean of ambiguity. No choice is better than the Nicene term hypostasis. This earliest of all creeds affirms that the Godhead is mia ousia and tres upostaseis. The term ousia is a participial noun from the verb to be; the translation commonly is being. A dog is a being, a rock is a being; but if ousia is simply a form of the verb am, are, is, be, then since there are dreams, dreams are: They are beings. Sometiems the term reality is used. But dreams, especially bad dreams, are real: They are real bad dreams. Plato claimed that his Ideas were realities: The Idea of Justice, the Idea of Man, the Idea of Horse, and the Idea of Number are realities. Therefore the term ousia is not a so good a basic term as hypostasis.
Another form of the verb 'to be' is esse or essence. The term can be useful, if defined. To illustrate: Someone sees a new gadget, or an animal he has never seen before. He asks, 'What is it?' His friend replies, 'It is this sort of gadget or this sort of animal.' In ordinary conversations the answer is usually incomplete, but if the friend is at all knowledgeable he gives a part of the definition. The full answer to the question 'What is it?' is the definition. Now, if the theologians had been content, or able to use the term unambiguously, a great deal of confusion would have been avoided. The essence is the definition. The essence of a plane triangle is an area bounded by three straight lines. The phrase 'it is of the essence. . .' means it is a part of the definition. Unfortunately many theologians do not explicitly say this, but often by usage deny it. In an historical survey, however, the author must reproduce the blunders of those whom he quotes."
Gordon H. Clark, Incarnation, Pg. 5-6
Wednesday, February 25, 2015
Was Christ only a human or also God in the flesh?
". . . assuming the existence of God and human souls, in fact accepting the Bible as the inerrant revelation of divine truth, we approach the main topic: the Incarnation of the Second Person of the Trinity. The approach, however, requires a statement of what the problem is. Since God is omnipotent, the question is not how such a stupendous event could be possible, but, rather, what precisely was this event.
The Scriptural assertions are clear enough as far as they go. In the Gospel of John (1:14) we read 'The Logos was made flesh.' John also says, 'Jesus Christ is come in the flesh . . . every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God, but this is the spirit of the anti-Christ.' Paul too, in 1 Timothy 3:16, insists that 'God was manifest in the flesh.' Nearly every verse in the Gospels presupposes an Incarnation. Similarly the epistles of Paul: Philippians 2:6-8; also 1 Peter 1:19, and by clear implication dozens of others.
But, (do you notice?) that while the flesh or body of Jesus is so frequently mentioned, these verses say nothing about the mind or soul of the person. That God wanted to impress us with the fact that the Second Person assumed a body is perfectly clear; but did he also wish to obscure the fact that the incarnate Christ had a human mind? That Christ assumed a body causes no difficulty to anyone who believes the Bible; but to understand how the Second Person could have a human soul and a be a human person (which virtually all orthodox Christians deny), and how that mind or soul was related to the divine Person is perhaps the most difficult problem in all theology. No one, Catholic, Calvinist, or atheist can deny that the Bible teaches an Incarnation. But an 'in-psuch-ation' troubled the church fathers over a period of 400 years. The results of their labors are at best woefully incomplete. Yet there is no better way to begin the subject than by tracing its history."
- Gordon H. Clark, The Incarnation
The Scriptural assertions are clear enough as far as they go. In the Gospel of John (1:14) we read 'The Logos was made flesh.' John also says, 'Jesus Christ is come in the flesh . . . every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God, but this is the spirit of the anti-Christ.' Paul too, in 1 Timothy 3:16, insists that 'God was manifest in the flesh.' Nearly every verse in the Gospels presupposes an Incarnation. Similarly the epistles of Paul: Philippians 2:6-8; also 1 Peter 1:19, and by clear implication dozens of others.
But, (do you notice?) that while the flesh or body of Jesus is so frequently mentioned, these verses say nothing about the mind or soul of the person. That God wanted to impress us with the fact that the Second Person assumed a body is perfectly clear; but did he also wish to obscure the fact that the incarnate Christ had a human mind? That Christ assumed a body causes no difficulty to anyone who believes the Bible; but to understand how the Second Person could have a human soul and a be a human person (which virtually all orthodox Christians deny), and how that mind or soul was related to the divine Person is perhaps the most difficult problem in all theology. No one, Catholic, Calvinist, or atheist can deny that the Bible teaches an Incarnation. But an 'in-psuch-ation' troubled the church fathers over a period of 400 years. The results of their labors are at best woefully incomplete. Yet there is no better way to begin the subject than by tracing its history."
- Gordon H. Clark, The Incarnation
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)